Showing posts with label modernist cuisine. Show all posts
Showing posts with label modernist cuisine. Show all posts

2023-11-04

Turbot with Creamy Leek Sauce a la Restaurant Le Jules Verne

My favorite dish at Restaurant Le Jules Verne (in the Eiffel Tower, Paris) was a Turbot with creamy leek sauce that was a bit fluffy: it was completely smooth and my photo hints it might have used an iSi whipper to get the light texture. It tasted distinctly of leeks and was topped by a couple charred stems of what looked like baby leeks which exuded a beckoning allium aroma. 

Merluza with Leek Sauce, charred Garlic shoots; served with Mashed Potatoes

I'm trying to reverse-enginerr this and expect it will take a few tries. This turned out pretty well, a tasty dish, good enough to serve to friends, but not an accurate recreation. It's worth trying again with some minor tweaks, but -- happily -- the sauce texture was rather good without resorting to an iSi and hydrocolloids; to pursue nerdiness for finesse and fluff, see below the recipe for leads.

Jules Verne had more green, finesse; and no side dish

I'm starting with proportions from Martha Stewart (who discards half of her batch and uses chicken stock), Charlotte Puckette (whose recipe is straight forward, adding parsley perhaps for color), and Food.com (which adds Lemon Juice instead of wine). 

David Lebovitz says to cook the leeks long and slow in butter with a bit of oil to prevent the butter from browning, and the comments say that letting them brown brings out bitter tastes. The Guardian (and others) says not to waste the green part as it has more flavor but should be cooked longer; it also suggests slicing the dark green parts thinly and then frying until crispy which seems like a good garnish.

For 2 portions:

250 g   1 giant  Leek, white to light green, cut in thin rings
 30 g       2 T  Butter
 15 ml      1 T  Olive Oil
 pinch           Salt
 60 ml    1/4 C  Dry White Wine
120 ml    1/2 C  Heavy Cream
  ?              Lime Juice (half of one lime, not all used)

  2 whole        Garlic Shoots [these have a Catalan name]

340 g            Turbot steaks (I used Merluza because I had it)
                 Olive Oil

Trim Leek root and ragged ends.
Slice from white part to green to quarter but leave bulb end intact; wash any sand, then slice thinly crosswise.


Sautée Leeks in Butter and Oil on low heat, covered, stirring occasionally, until quite soft, about 20 minutes. 
Add Wine, increase heat, and reduce until evaporated.
Add Cream and simmer 5 minutes.
Transfer to blender and whiz until it won't get any smoother.
I had to add another 90 ml Wine because it was too thick to blend well.
The result was fairly fluffy -- not as airy as Jules Verne's, but good enough for serving.
Strain through a medium sieve: I had 350 g before, 290 g after sieving.

Trim the Garlic Shoots, slice carefully lengthwise, and cook on a heavy pan to brown. Use a filim of oil since we're trying to char and crisp, not sautée. Cover and weigh down; I used a chunk of granite kitchen counter top sample. Cook on medium, carefully turning to brown both sides. Try and brown the stems too.


The restaurant menu said "cuit au naturel", which we believe translates as steam or poach. My interpretation is they don't want to give the fish any color or flavor from browning you'd get from a sautée.
This didn't occur to me, this time, so I filmed a pan with Olive Oil, and cooked the Merluza (Hake) fairly slowly, covered, to avoid browning. Season with Salt and flip when about half done. Flip once more and check the fish to see if it flakes readily.

While the fish cooks, heat the Leek Sauce; if it sags, fluff with a whisk.

To serve, put a layer of sauce on the plate, add the fish, and top with more sauce.
Garnish with the browed Garlic Shoots.

Served with golden mashed potatoes, too similar in color.

Tasting

This is good, but not leek-y enough. And not green enough. Not what I was aiming for -- a faithful rendition of a Michelin-starred restaurant dish --  but I'd be happy to serve this to friends, even fancy foodie friends. I'd like more leek-taste and Irene wanted less butter.

The Merluza/Hake had a good texture, large firm flakes when cooked gently to 57C/135F or a bit above.


Next time...

Use one 150g Leek, not a 250g behemouth. 
Use dark green leek bits to get more flavor and the deeper color that Jules Verne had. 
Blanch and shock the green parts first so they don't turn grey when cooking.

Less butter: there was plenty for the 250g leek, so cut the butter at least in half.

Since I had to add Wine to thin it enough to blend, why add the Wine to the pan and reduce it away? Instead, add to blender, then cook off after blended and strained, so we can get the saucy texture we want.

Use Turbot, since that's what Jules Verne used. Or not: the Merluza/Hake was good for this -- firm with large flakes.
Cook the fish sous vide from frozen ("naturale" on the menu suggests steamed or poached).

Fry some green leek rings, or rings from the garlic shoots.

When charring the garlic shoots, use a minuscule film of oil: we want the char.

There was no color contrast when served with mashed potatoes. There wasn't much contrast between the Merluza and the Leek Sauce either. Try and get a more intensely green sauce. Serve a side dish of a very different color: arroz negro, sepia ink pasta,...,  something more dramatic. Or use Salmon for the fish: we don't have to use Turbot or anything similar.

To get a really fluffy/airy texture, try the iSi Whipper with Agar Agar fluid gel. It'll be a lot more work but it's "'playing with your food". 

iSi Whipper for Fluffy "Espuma"

TL;DR: after reading the below, I'd try the following:

After the first medium sieve,  I'd run it through a fine sieve to prevent clogging the iSi. Then add back to the pan, add 0.6-1.0% by weight of Agar, bring to simmer for 5 minutes, then chill until gelled. Whiz to make a fluid gel, heat to serving temperature, 65C/150F, then put in the iSi. Charge with an N2O cylinder and hold at serving temperature in a water bath.

Below are links to techniques and materials:

How can I use an iSi whipper to make a hot foamy sauce, an "espuma"? In my research for Bacalao Espuma, I found Xanthan and Agar Agar didn't gel well, and ended up using potato for the starch.

Cuisine Technology points out "milk holds bubbles better while hot, and cream does better when it’s cold", and "starches is that they work in either hot or cold" but we want to avoid it getting too thick. Also "Lecithin works (and dissolves) in both hot and cold water", and that Agar, once set, will stabilize up to 185F/85C so fine for a hot foam, but the procedure is a bit complicated in that you have to make a "fluid gel".

Amazing Food Made Easy talks about fluid gel foams, amongst others. 

There are pointers to lots of inventive preparations on Molecular Recipes. This one for an clam chowder espuma doesn't use anything to bolster the cream before going into an iSi whipper -- like I used in this first attempt for leek cream sauce. 

2017-12-25

Sous Vide Bacalao Pil Pil

Cooking the Bacalao sous vide allows us to use much less oil than our previous modernist approach, while perfectly cooking the fish and capturing the essential gelatin that gives us the Pil Pil emulsion.

Bacalao with Pil Pil sauce, Catalan style greens, Pa amb tomàquet
Previously, we'd used the science-based technique we learned from Basque chefs: they completely submerged the Bacalo in enough oil to cover and gently cooked to release the gelatin required for this sauce. This is much less work and much more reliable than the traditional method of sliding the fish back and forth in a pan with a little oil to release the gelatin, but it left us with a huge amount of fishy oil that we had to find a use for.

This time, we reasoned that we could use much less oil if we cooked the fish in a sous vide bag, and it would be trivial to capture the released gelatin.  It would also allow us to cook the fish very gently in a controlled manner.

We had gotten a big frozen chunk of skin-on, bone-in Bacalo from a Portuguese market. We believe it was salted like traditional Bacalao but it had been rehydrated to desalinate before freezing.

370 g     Bacalao (rehydrated to desalinate)
4   clove Garlic
1         Chili Arbol, seeded
250 ml    Olive Oil, good quality
1   pinch Salt

Seal Bacalao, Garlic, Chili, and Olive oil in sous vide bag.



Cook sous vide at 78C/172F for 30 minutes. When you remove the bag from the bath, you should see the white liquid gelatin below the fish and oil.

White gelatin elixir below Bacalao, oil

Pour off the liquid into a tall narrow container and allow to separate. Use a turkey baster to extract the gelatin from the bottom to another tall narrow glass. Repeat separation until you've got one container of oil and one of gelatin; it's all right if it's not perfect.

First settling
Second separation, mostly gelatin; oil is in the bowl on the right

To make the Pil Pil sauce, add 10-15 ml (2-3 tsp) of the white gelatin liquid to a pan and turn on very low heat.  Whip to incorporate air; I used a mesh scum skimmer which worked very well, but a fork or whisk should also do.  When frothy with fine bubbles, drizzle in a few drops of the oil. Continue whipping until a stable emulsion forms. Add more oil, a little at a time, and incorporate until you have the volume you need. If the emulsion starts to break or if it becomes too thick for your taste, add a splash of hot water and whip to incorporate. I took the pan off the heat and did most of this on the counter, as it seemed even the low heat was encouraging the sauce to break. Adjust taste with salt.

Whisk oil into gelatin with mesh skimmer to form emulsion

Plate cooked fish, and top with Pil Pil sauce.  We served ours with mustard greens cooked Catalan style with sultanas, toasted pine nuts and garlic; and Pa amb Tomàquet (toasted bread rubbed with garlic and topped with -- in our case -- tomato pulp instead of being rubbed with fresh tomato).

Save the rest of the precious gelatin; we froze ours.

What Worked, What Didn't

Everything worked beautifully with this technique: we got a bunch of precious fish elixir to use and to save for a future batch; we didn't end up with liters of excess fish oil; the fish was nicely cooked, and the Pil Pil sauce had a good texture.

Now that we've figured this out, a simple search shows us we are not the first to do it this way; duh.

Next Time

How low can we drop the heat and still extract the gelatin elixir? 78C seems a bit high to cook fish, can we drop it to 55C/131F where the gelatin is supposed to first start releasing? Does Bacalao need the higher temperature? Would other fresh (unsalted/rehydrated) fish be better at lower temperatures? One recipe we found recipe uses 65C/150F for 30 minutes.

Try traditional dry salted Bacalao; we have noticed that none of the boneless pieces had skin on, and the skin may be where all the gelatin lives.

Since we use so little oil and there not much effort, we can try other fish species; we've already ascertained Mahi Mahi works (and Sea Trout did not). What others will release gelatin for an emulsion?

Other Work

In 2022 we recreated this in our Barcelona apartment, at 55C for 30 minutes but pointed out 45-60 might be better. 

While looking for other sous vide bacalao recipes, I found two videos which provide more ideas. 

This first, which was done in 2015 and therefore predates mine, cooked at 65C for 30 minutes, and used the same strainer-in-skillet technique I did to create an emulsion from the "fish water", what I called "elixer. 

The next, from 2021, streamlines it even further: she cooks the fish sous vide at 60C for 20 minutes, but without adding any oil. She then drains off the fish liquid elixir into a cup, no oil separation required, and creates the emulsion with a stick blender, adding in the garlic-oil to build the sauce -- brilliant. She adds a bit of honey to each bag.

This one from 2020 is nearly identical, but he cooks at 48C for 20-30 minutes before emulsifying the fish liquid with a stick blender, then adding oil. He cooks the garlic in oil in a jar in the same bath as the fish, so he doesn't even need a sauté pan. He adds some membrillo to each bag. 

2014-04-27

Bacalao Espuma


Scandinavia produces a lot of salt cod -- Tørfisk, Klippfisk, Clipfish. They can dry it in the cold air without worrying about spoilage. I first had it in Spain, as Bacalao, and fell in love with the slightly funky flavor it contributes to dishes.

For a Scandinavian dinner, I wanted a stable warm foam, or "espuma", to top a birch-wrapped, sous vide cooked cod fillet. I wanted to double-down on the cod.

From previous attempts, I've found it hard to keep a foam stable at high temperatures: whipped cream preparations are typically served cold. My additions of Agar Agar and even Xanthan Gum (in small amounts) didn't help much. I was looking for something almost as thick and solid as whipped cream, or at least shaving foam.  Ferran Adriá refers to these warm temperature foams as Espumas so I will follow suit.

Here, I synthesize what I hope is a simple but stable Bacalao-flavored espuma. This is a condiment so I don't need a ton; I'm targetting a 1.0L iSi Thermo Whip so a maximum of about 0.5L product.

To top 6 filets

  • 250     g       Bacalo, bone- and skinless, rehydrated and desalted
  • 250     g       Potato, peeled
  • 250     ml      Heavy Cream


Rehydrate the Bacalao and soak in water for 2-3 days, changing the water 2-3 times a day to remove much of the preservative salt.  Cut it up fine so it will stay submerged in the Cream.

Simmer the Bacalao very low in Heavy Cream to infuse flavor, 30-60 minutes. You don't want it to bubble and reduce. (A sous vide bath might be helpful for this).  [I might need more Cream to Bacalao]

Meanwhile peel potato and cube, and boil 20 minutes until just cooked.  (Can I just cook the potato in the cream for 20 minutes?)

Thoroughly blend cooked potatoes and Bacalao cream, preferably in a Vitamix. While it whipped, it did NOT create a whipped cream: this was in retrospect a bit of a surprise; why not? Does this bode ill for the espuma?

Strain through coarse then very fine mesh seive. This gave me 400ml of bacalao-potato-cream.

Pour into iSi Thermomix. Check your volume, it should not be more than half full.  Charge with 2 N2O cream cylinders and shake vigorously. Hold in a water bath at a max of 75C (165F) until ready for service.


Resources

Below, I cite a number of recipes and resources from around the web. Some use additional flavors (shallots, coconut cream, chicken stock, cheese) but I wanted to let the Bacalao flavor dominate. The techniques I kept finding seemed to use heavy cream and potato: the fat from the cream will foam, and the starch in the potato may provide some stabilization.

iSi Potato Celeriac Foam (75C)

http://www.isi.com/en/culinary/for-professionals/recipes/recipes/recipe-of-the-month/?tx_isirecipes_recipes%5Brecipe%5D=1372&tx_isirecipes_recipes%5Baction%5D=show&tx_isirecipes_recipes%5Bcontroller%5D=Recipe

150 g Potatoes (floury)
75 ml heavy cream
75 ml Water
50 g Butter
75 g pureed celeriac
1 g Salt
1 g Pepper
1 g Nutmeg

Bring the cream and water to a boil in a pot and then, along with the boiled potatoes, blend into a fine puree. Add the pureed celeriac and the butter little by little then season to taste with salt, pepper and nutmeg. Pass through the iSi funnel & sieve directly into the 0.5 L iSi Whipper, screw on 1 iSi cream charger and shake vigorously. Keep the iSi Whipper warm at max. 75 °C in a bain-marie or in a water bath.


Espuma caliente de grasa de foie gras

http://vimeo.com/37517154
Xanthan 2.5g
Chick stock 300g
Whiz wiht immersion blenter very well
Add pepper, salt
Melt foie gras, add to Xanthan stock, whiz well
Striain, add to siphon
2 charges N2O
Hold at 70C

Potato Espuma

http://www.thestaffcanteen.com/recipe/potato-espuma/
600g cooked potatoes
450g hot double cream
150g hot milk
seasoning

Boil potatoes just until cooked, drain and slightly cool, peel and mash potatoes Add seasoning, add hot liquids and check seasoning adjust were needed, pass through double sieve, place into charger and use two charges and keep warm at 55oc

Pea Espuma (warm)

http://www.isi.com/en/culinary/for-professionals/recipes/recipes/vegetable-espumas/?tx_isirecipes_recipes%5Brecipe%5D=1104&tx_isirecipes_recipes%5Baction%5D=show&tx_isirecipes_recipes%5Bcontroller%5D=Recipe&cHash=635b0b38457dffc706c8fab2c5c212fc

200 ml heavy cream
100 g Peas
150 g Potatoes

Peel the Potatoes, cook until soft and mash with a potato masher. Blanch the Peas and puree in a blender until smooth. Heat the Heavy Cream, mix with the potatoes and the pea puree and season with salt, nutmeg and 50 ml mint oil. Pass through the iSi funnel & sieve directly into the 0.5 L iSi Whipper, screw on 1 iSi cream charger and shake vigorously. Keep the iSi Whipper warm at max. 75 °C · 165 °F in a bain-marie or in a water bath.


Potato foam 

250 g potatoes, peeled and cut into chunks
125 g single cream
30 g virgin olive oil, plus extra for drizzling

Place the potatoes in a pan of cold water, bring to the boil, and cook for about 20 minutes until soft. Drain, reserving 100 g of the cooking water. Place the cooked potato and the water in a blender. Purée, adding the cream little by little. Follow the same procedure with the oil until you have a smooth emulsion. Season with salt. Strain, then fill the siphon using a funnel.  Charge with nitrous oxide, shake, and keep warm in a bain-marie at 70 ºC.  Ferran Adria via http://www.chubbyhubby.net


elBulli Hot potato foam

http://www.foodsfromspain.com/icex/cda/controller/pageSGT/0,9459,35868_6908153_6910167_4459102,00.html
250 gr potatoes for mashing
100 gr potato cooking water
125 gr cream, 35% fat content
35 gr extra virgin olive oil
500 ml ISI siphon
2 N2O chargers
salt

Peel and cut the potatoes and place in cold, salted water. Bring to the boil and cook for approximately 20 minutes. When cooked, drain and reserve the water. Place the cooked potato and 100 g / 3 1/2 oz cooking water in the Thermomix at 60ºC / 140ºF. Blend and gradually pour in the cream. Do the same with the oil until a very thin, smooth emulsion is formed. Season with salt. Strain and fill the siphon using a funnel. Charge the siphon and place in a bain-marie at approx. 70ºC / 158ºF.